Is Desire a Qualification for Ministry?
Is the desire for ministry a qualification for pastors? If I have a desire for ministry—or if I don’t—how should I understand that biblically?

Tony has served as the Pastor-Teacher of Woodland Park Bible Church since January 2025 and is currently earning an MDiv at The Master’s Seminary. He and his wife Beki have been married since 2007 and have four children.
‘We had a guy who served for many years as a faithful deacon. He taught Sunday school, he had a great family, and we approached him several times about being an elder, but he just had no desire for it, so he remained a deacon.’
Something like that is commonly heard in discussions about the qualifications for pastoral leadership in 1 Timothy 3. There the apostle Paul begins with this: “The saying is trustworthy: If anyone aspires to the office of overseer, he desires a noble task” (1 Timothy 3:1, ESV). This “trustworthy saying” is commonly understood as a desire for ministry. It is the “desire qualification,” as many have called it. If a man is going to be qualified to serve as an elder, he must first of all have the desire to serve as an elder.
But is that what Paul is actually saying?
What 1 Timothy 3:1–2 Actually Says
Here are the parts of verses 1–2 in Paul’s original Greek that are important for answering that question, followed by a literal translation:
Εἴ τις ἐπισκοπῆς ὀρέγεται, καλοῦ ἔργου ἐπιθυμεῖ. δεῖ οὖν τὸν ἐπίσκοπον ἀνεπίλημπτον εἶναι…
Lit: “If someone aspires [to be] an overseer, he desires a good work. It is necessary, therefore, [for] the elder to be above reproach…”
This is obviously followed by roughly a dozen more qualifications that a man must meet if he is legitimately going to serve as a pastor in a local church.
Notice what Paul’s actual opening statement is in this section: “If someone aspires [to be] an overseer, he desires a good work.” What is he saying? In normal human communication where words create sentences that convey complete, coherent thoughts, what is being communicated? Is Paul saying that “it is necessary” for a man to aspire to the work of an overseer? Clearly he is not. The “necessary” things—that is, the qualifications—are the things that follow the little word δεῖ (dei, lit. “it is necessary”). The “necessary” requirements for pastoral leadership are the things that Paul says are “necessary” for an elder, beginning with “[being] above reproach.”
What, then, is Paul saying with respect to desire? Well, if we simply take his words for what they actually mean as indicated by what he’s actually saying, then what he means is this: ‘If a man desires to be a pastor, that’s great; it’s a good thing to want.’
Is Paul saying that “it is necessary” for a man to aspire to the work of an overseer? Clearly he is not. The “necessary” requirements for pastoral leadership are the things that Paul says are “necessary” for an elder, beginning with “[being] above reproach.”
Paul is demonstrably saying nothing about desire as a requirement for ministry. In fact, if we let him speak for himself, he may even be doing the opposite. That is, he may well be acknowledging that a lot of people want things that are good to want, and leadership in the local church is one of those things. Therefore, in order to mitigate against people getting into leadership who have no business being there—regardless of whether or not they “feel” like God is calling them to it—Paul says in verses 2 and following that “it is necessary” to make sure that every pastor meets God’s standard for leadership.
As one old commentary says, “‘Well might a man desire the office of chief pastor; it was indeed a good work;’ but, in the first place, such a dignity could only be held by one possessing many qualities, then and there enumerated.”
Why Does “the Desire Qualification” Exist?
If Paul does not make desire a qualification for ministry—and if his actual words mean what they actually mean, he doesn’t—then why do we hear so often that it is?
It seems, from our humble perspective, that there are two reasons.
The first reason is that Paul talks about desire in the general context of pastoral qualifications, plain and simple. Since qualifications are clearly the main point of the passage, and since desire appears in the general vicinity, anchoring takes over, and desire gets included along with the actual qualifications.
And maybe it’s understandable, because the precise nuance of Paul’s ‘desire’ statement is not obvious. (Of course, I think the nuance is how I’ve described it in this article.) So what you have, then, is a statement about “desire” that is a little ambiguous in its relationship to the qualifications. As a result—and this isn’t meant to be a dig, but a technical critique—rather than do the more difficult work of exegesis based on a literal, grammatical, historical hermeneutic—that is, rather than allowing authorial intent to determine the meaning of the phrase in the flow of the argument—it gets glossed over and absorbs a meaning by osmosis from the qualifications, which are the main point in the context.
The second reason, though—and probably following that—is that the ‘desire qualification’ has been repeated so long and by so many faithful voices that it’s virtually the accepted meaning of the text today.
Take, for example, the following quote by Martyn Lloyd-Jones:
It was Mr. Spurgeon, I believe, who used to say to young men—“If you can do anything else do it. If you can stay out of the ministry, stay out of the ministry.” I would certainly say that without any hesitation whatsoever. I would say that the only man who is called to preach is the man who cannot do anything else, in the sense that he is not satisfied with anything else. This call to preach is so put upon him, and such pressure comes to bear upon him that he says, “I can do nothing else, I must preach.” (Martyn Lloyd-Jones, Preaching & Preachers (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1971), 105.)
There are many things we would like to say about this, but the main point is that desire has been commended as a qualification for ministry for so long and by so many faithful men that it is virtually accepted as gospel truth and as the settled meaning of 1 Timothy 3:1.
Now, what we do not intend to do here is slam every faithful man who asserts a ‘desire qualification.’ (There are too many, and I am just one guy—one scrub, one shmo, one nobody—who, in this case, also happens to be swimming against the current.) What we do intend is to plead for a responsible handling of the text. Let’s let the text say what it means, and let’s not make it out to mean things that it doesn’t mean in the interests of our own or anyone else’s ideas no matter how noble they seem.
We make a huge deal about expository preaching—and rightly so—because our bedrock conviction is that the text means what the text says. It doesn’t matter what Scripture means to me. What matters is what it meant to the inspired author, and what the author meant is what God means, so that is the meaning I must seek and insist upon, and anyone who doesn’t like it can take it up with the Lord Jesus.
So… Is Desire a Qualification for Ministry?
No, desire is not a qualification for pastoral ministry.
If we’re going to allow Paul to speak for himself and if the text means what the text says, then his ‘desire’ statement is ultimately a qualitative statement about pastoral ministry—ministry is a ‘good work,’ a good thing for a man to want—but it says nothing about desire as a qualification.
Again, the qualifications for ministry are the things that are explicitly stated as being ‘necessary’ for a man to possess, and those have to do with gifting and character. Desire is not among those necessary things and has nothing to do with gifting or character. At the end of the day, desire is simply a feeling, and it providentially may or may not accord with something God is doing in me or through me.
This isn’t a matter of biblical qualifications, by the way. It’s a matter of the meaning of the authoritative text.
The qualifications for ministry are the things that are explicitly stated as being ‘necessary’ to a man’s character. Desire is not among those necessary things and has nothing to do with gifting or character.
But that raises an important question: If desire is not a qualification for ministry, what do we do with that desire? There are at least four things we can say about it.
1. Recognize that desire is not ultimately an indication of anything.
A lot of people want a lot of things. A lot of people want to win American Idol who can’t carry a tune in a bucket, and yet many of them are convinced they will win American Idol.
A lot of people believe God has called them to something. I have heard Paula White say with my own ears that she is positive God has called her to be a pastor.
A lot of people want a lot of good things. Wanting to be a pastor is a good thing. But just because someone wants a good thing doesn’t mean that it’s something they should legitimately be wanting. Plus, not all good things are wanted for the right reasons. The desire for ministry is great so far as it goes, because, as we’ve said elsewhere, New Testament pastoral ministry is such a crucially important need in the world. But it is for that very reason that “it is necessary [for] the elder” to meet a number of non-negotiable qualifications, none of which include desire.
Desire is fine, but character and gifting is what counts. And character and gifting are not self-assessed, neither are they created because I “feel” like God is calling me to do something or because I happen to want to do something. Rather, character and gifting are recognized and affirmed by God’s people and by other qualified leaders (1 Timothy 3:2–7, 2 Timothy 2:2).
So, if I’m a person who desires ministry, what I should not do is get hung up on that desire or take it as a sign of God’s will for my life. It may or may not coincide with God’s plans for me, and in fact it might even be the fruit of sinful, fleshly desires or self-deceit.
What I should do above all is focus on my character. Like one of my old professors used to say, “If you have character, you’ll have ministry.”
2. Don’t make desire a qualification issue.
In keeping with the gift of teaching—which is the unique, Spirit-given ability to understand, explain, and apply the Word of God—let’s handle the Word responsibly. Let’s not make 1 Timothy 3:1 out to mean something that Paul didn’t intend. If anything, 1 Timothy 3:1 is a pre-qualification checkpoint: ‘Ok, so you have a desire for ministry? That’s great—but before we let you in we need to take a look at your character and gifting.’
3. Don’t make desire a condition for serving.
On the surface, it sounds very noble when someone says, ‘We wanted him to be an elder, but he just didn’t have the desire.’ But apply that line of reasoning to any other area of service: ‘We wanted her to teach Sunday school—we certainly had a need—but she didn’t have the desire.’ ‘We really needed a couple extra people to serve on the Saturday bathroom cleaning crew, but he said he didn’t have the desire.’
There is no other area of service within the local church that we treat that way. What good men recognize for themselves, and what we rightly commend to our people, is that you don’t serve because you want to. You serve because there’s a need and you can meet it.
In fact, I suspect that most leaders would see it as a potential flaw in someone’s character if they are able to serve but won’t because they don’t want to.
No other area of service gets that kind of pass, and we do not see one reason why pastoral ministry is any different.
Now, what we never want to do is twist someone’s arm, or force them to do something that they really, really don’t want to do. But instead of giving good, qualified men a pass because we’ve misinterpreted the text, we should treat eldership the same way we treat every other area service: If you’re qualified and able, you should serve whether you want to or not precisely because the need for godly, qualified leaders is so appallingly great.
If you’re qualified and able, you should serve whether you want to or not precisely because the need for godly, qualified leaders is so appallingly great.
At the end of the day, all Christians need to be willing to work, or serve, or commit, or endure, or [fill in the blank with any other Christian imperative], not because they want to, but because it’s the will of God and it’s the right thing to do.
4. Be thankful for the desire if I am qualified and I happen to have the desire.
There is much we could say here, but suffice it to say that, for a man who loves Christ’s sheep and who desires above all else to see them perfected in Christ-likeness—for a man who loves the Word of God, and who (like MacArthur says) isn’t looking for something to say but for someone to say it to—for a man who has a high view of God, a high view of Scripture, and a high view of the church—for a man who is jealous for the glory of God like Phinehas—for a man who is prepared to stare down the culture like Jeremiah, come what may…
For a man like that to be able to spend his life laboring in the Word and doctrine, loving the people of God, devoting himself to prayer and the ministry of the Word—and to actually get paid to do it!—is, in the understatement of all understatements, a privilege.
So if I am a man who is in ministry and I have the desire for it, I should be overflowing with thankfulness to God, and I should roll up my sleeves, and I should gladly get to work.
Related:
A Pastoral Podcast, Leadership, Preaching

