When People Who Say They’re Christians Turn Out to Be Monsters
We went to church with them, knew them personally, had dinner in their home. But they weren't who they said they were. How should a Christian respond to that?

Tony has served as the Pastor-Teacher of Woodland Park Bible Church since January 2025 and is currently earning an MDiv at The Master’s Seminary. He and his wife Beki have been married since 2007 and have four children.
Last week I got one of the most disturbing updates I’ve ever received about anyone I’ve ever gone to church with. It involved serious, heartbreaking crimes against children, and it horrifies me to think that I had children of my own at the church that we attended together. None of these things happened during those years, nor was anyone at our church a victim. But it’s still a sobering reminder that our fallen, sin-cursed world is dangerous, dark, and uncertain, and the church is not exempt from it.
Disappointments—even unimaginable ones that shake our faith and rock our sensibilities—are going to happen. But how should Christians think about it when they do? I have several thoughts.
1. Christians should be humble and suspicious of self.
That man eventually left our church (long before his arrest) because he was disgruntled over preference issues. His complaints had nothing to do with truth versus error, or sin versus righteousness—but he didn’t see it that way. He wanted things done a certain way, and they weren’t being done that way, so he felt like he was being wronged. There were several people—including at least three pastors—who tried to reason with him for several months to help him understand that he wasn’t seeing things accurately, but he wouldn’t hear it. He was absolutely sure that he was right and everyone else was wrong and that he had been wronged. So he left.
Arrogant self-confidence is a stock feature of our fallen nature. There is probably nothing more standard and ubiquitous among humanity than our infinite capacity for being dead wrong about something while thinking we’re right. This is why we need to embrace humility and self-suspicion.
When many mature, godly believers and proven leaders all agree that you’re going about something the wrong way—especially when they’ve all loved you and served you and invested in you—the biblical response is self-doubt and careful self-examination. In those kinds of situations, the worst thing you can do is harden up, get defensive, and bunker down in self-confidence. Tragically, that is exactly what that man did.
Stubborn self-will is a major character flaw. God says that self-willed people are unqualified for leadership (see Titus 1:7). But as this situation reminds me, self-will could also be an indication of issues that are much deeper and darker. Scandalous, life-destroying sins by professing Christians need to remind us to cultivate humility in ourselves and to encourage and look for it in others.
2. Christians need accountable, open lives.
As believers, we simply cannot have corners of our lives that are inaccessible to human eyes. I have to have people in my life who know where I’m going, what I’m doing, who I’m with, and what I’m looking at.
I don’t know about this man’s life prior to our time together at church. I don’t know if he was a previous offender, and I never had a reason to suspect anything of the kind. I don’t know what was going on in his heart and mind before all these things happened. I don’t know any of that. We weren’t that close.
What I do know is that this kind of sin almost never happens without a whole bunch of compromises and sins leading up to it. Especially when it comes to sexual sin, catastrophic failures are almost always the result of some unlawful desire of the heart that was harbored and nurtured in secret, sometimes for years.
“Scandalous, life-destroying sins by professing Christians should first remind us to cultivate humility in ourselves.”
We have to guard our hearts (Proverbs 4:23). The battle must start in the heart, because that’s where the war of life is ultimately won or lost. “May my heart be blameless in your statutes, that I may not be put to shame!” (Psalm 119:80, emphasis added). The problem, of course, is that no one can hold me accountable in my heart. In my heart I am utterly alone before God; God alone can hold me accountable there.
Those who are doing the hard, biblical work of keeping themselves accountable in their heart before God are seeking accountability. Their lives are open books. They’re pursuing people, not isolation, and they welcome the spotlight in their lives because they know what they’re capable of. And ‘what they’re capable of’ doesn’t have to be something that’s horrifically unspeakable or illegal, because any sin can destroy many lives if given a long enough leash. Mature believers hate sin because it’s sin no matter what sin it is. They know that the biggest problem in their lives is in the mirror—or rather, behind their sternum—and that terrifies them. So they seek out the light rather than the darkness by pursing and welcoming accountability.
Seeking and welcoming accountability is a sign of spiritual maturity. Isolation and social detachment are signs of spiritual immaturity or worse (John 3:19–20). As believers, we should seek accountability for ourselves, and we should take careful note of those who isolate themselves and who avoid accountability.
3. Churches need to vet those they entrust with responsibility.
In the Lord’s mercy, the man I’m talking about in this article was not in leadership, nor was he serving in any capacity connected to children. If he had been serving around children, he would have been fingerprinted and background-checked—a standard practice in every church that takes the Bible seriously and has a children’s ministry. Even so, this whole situation should remind us of the importance of vetting people before they’re put in positions of responsibility.
Church membership is a simple, effective, responsible means of vetting people. Obviously, it cannot prevent tragedies from happening, but it does provide an important safeguard that mitigates against them. Unsurprisingly, there are some church insurance companies that won’t cover churches in incidents where the offender is not a member.1
Church membership protects the church by helping to keep the wolves out. It’s not fail-proof, but it goes a long way toward protecting lives and resources. When we hear about professing Christians who turn out to be monsters, it should cause us to double down on the goodness and the necessity of church membership as an important vetting mechanism.
Church membership is a responsible first line of defense.
When a person applies for membership in a biblical local church, their beliefs and lives are examined to ensure that they conform to the biblical standard. According to Scripture, people who are genuinely born again believe truths that the Bible identifies as essential, and their lives are characterized by obedience to Christ. It is only those people who can be welcomed into the church’s fellowship (see 1 Corinthians 5).
Typically, biblical local churches will limit leadership and service opportunities to those who are members. At Woodland Park, we’ve actually written that policy into our bylaws (see WPBC’s Bylaws, Section 5.5). The reason for that is simple: The Lord Jesus has entrusted his sheep to the care of the church’s elders, and his people have voluntarily given their own money for the needs of other believers and the advancement of his Gospel. His command and expectation is that we be faithful with those people and those assets. Church membership is a simple, biblical way of vetting people to help ensure that only responsible people are put in positions of responsibility.
Church membership is a simple litmus test for humility and reasonableness.
There are probably no character qualities that are more destructive than pride and irrationality. Church membership is a simple way of identifying humble, reasonable people.
Arrogant people are not humble, not servants, not able to honor laws, norms, or leadership. They are, by nature of the case, autonomous—literally “their own law.” Arrogant people undermine the stability, unity, and productiveness of families, churches, businesses, and entire societies. “Humble” or “gentle” is what Jesus was (Matthew 11:29), and believers are called to be humble and gentle about two dozen times in the NT. Arrogant people are neither humble nor gentle. They are defiant and conceited. They are self-confident and self-centered, and they should not be trusted with anything.
Unreasonable people cannot be reasoned with because they are, by definition, irrational. They are nearsighted and unable to discern what is good and right (see Hebrews 5:14). When they’re not calling evil good and good evil, they’re causing division because they lack the maturity to know the difference between hills to die on and legitimate differences of conscience, preference, or conviction. Reasonableness is a qualification for leaders (1 Timothy 3:3) because believers need to be fair-minded, level-headed, and able to accurately assess a situation. They need the ability to heed advice and to be corrected when wrong, because that’s what you need if you’re going to deal wisely and gently with everyone.2 Unreasonable people do not have any of those abilities.
“There are probably no character qualities that are more destructive than pride and irrationality. Church membership is a simple way of identifying humble, reasonable people.”
There are many people today who say that church membership is unbiblical. This is no surprise given how twistedly individualistic our antisocial culture has become. I agree that it’s unbiblical to say—like the Roman Catholic Church says3—that “If you don’t belong to this church, you’re going to hell.” But that, of course, is not what biblical local churches are saying, nor is it what those who are opposed to church membership are responding to. Instead, in my universal experience in over 20 years as a believer, a person’s resistance to church membership invariably springs from arrogance, unreasonableness, or both.
The entire Bible calls Christians to a vital, active commitment to the local church. Formal church membership is not the only way of putting that commitment into practice, but it is definitely a wise, reasonable, biblical way of doing it. People who are humble and reasonable will recognize that.
4. Moral monstrosities vindicate the Lord Jesus and the Word of God.
Bad examples give blasphemers an opportunity to blaspheme (see Romans 2:24, 1 Timothy 6:1, and Titus 2:5–8). It is also true that only “the church victorious will be the church at rest.” Wolves and hypocrites will grow up among the Lord’s people until Christ returns (Matthew 13:24–30). Scandal, sin, and betrayal are going to rock the church and hinder its advancement until the Lord Jesus sits enthroned on the earth and all eyes behold him (Ezekiel 37:24–28).
But mark it down: Scandals vindicate Christ and the Word of God even while the opportunists seize the chance to celebrate and blaspheme.
Sin against children is “sin” because God says so. By default, man disagrees.
When scandals like these happen, the critics of Christianity have a field day. I remember working in an environment full of secular progressive elites in a very “California” part of California when the Duggar scandal resurfaced in the 2010s. I don’t recall the details, but what an opportunity that was for all of my coworkers! As the only Christian in the building—and even as the only “person of color” (in a day when that kind of thing is said to matter)—I didn’t get a pass. I was guilty by association, because Christianity was the real guilty party.
Of course, it’s only within a Protestant framework that these kinds of moral monstrosities are actually moral monstrosities. In the ancient Roman and Greek worlds, pedophilia was routine. In the Islamic world, marriages to girls under 10 years of age are commonplace, and many of those marriages are forced. For decades, secular postmodern academics in the West have been advocating for the destigmatization—and in some cases, the decriminalization—of assault on children. Michel Foucault, for instance—that great western Elijah and champion of its chief doctrine of total sexual liberation—is the most quoted person in academia and evidently in human history. As another example, a primary progressive concern since 2020 has been securing the rights of drag queens to do striptease performances in front of young children. As another, children in public schools remain somewhere between 60 and 100 times more likely to be sexually abused than children in Catholic churches.4 Many more examples could be cited.
But none of this is a surprise given that children are autonomous sexual beings according to our brave new worldview. Sexualization should start in early elementary school, and not even parents have the right to interfere with a child’s sexuality or gender identity. But that, in turn, is no surprise given that personhood is no longer found in the imago Dei but in sexuality. As Carl Trueman has observed, sex in the modern West is identity, not activity—it’s who I am, not something I do.
Secular postmodernism has given rise to a culture in which personhood is grounded in personal sexual desires, and the goal and meaning of life is the satisfaction of every urge with the physical and the material. People have no souls; they’re simply “clumps of cells” that exist for the sole purpose of satisfying the glandular urges of other “clumps of cells.” This is why “being true to yourself” boils down to absolute sexual autonomy, without limits or consequences, and why “self-care” often includes “going no contact.” It’s all because people are objects in my universe, and their worth is bound up in the pleasure I get from them.
In virtually any other worldview—including a secular progressive worldview—what we call “pedophilia” is either common or legitimate. The biblical Scriptures have been unique in human history in creating a culture that abominates the abuse of children and that elevates their dignity, status, and value. The only reason Whitney Houston believed that children are our future is because she was a product of “these Christian times,” as Augustine phrased it. In the same way, the only reason that the critics of Christianity find these kinds of scandals so scandalizing is because they’re still thoroughly and conveniently Protestant in certain aspects of their basic outlook.
The fact that the West is appalled by the evil of wicked people against children (at least for now) is because we are the products of a worldview that has been shaped by the morality of the Christian Scriptures. To borrow from Romans 3:20, it is only through the Scripture that we have the knowledge of sin against children.
Sin against children only happens when people disobey the Word of God.
Those who profess to be Christians yet prove to be monsters have departed from the Christ they claim. It’s not because of their obedience to Scripture that they did what they did. It was because they rejected the Word of God, and the glory of Christ, and the worthwhile holiness that Christ purchased for us at the cost of his own blood. They did what they did because they rejected and disobeyed the Word of God in fifty ways—from the act itself, to the abuse of their authority, to the hiding of it and lying about it, and several dozen others.
Even though these kinds of scandals fill us with horror and anger and heartbreak, they should strengthen our confidence in the righteousness, holiness, and goodness of the Lord Jesus and the Word of God. They should vindicate the Word of God in our minds, because it is only by His standard that evil is evil, and it is only by rejecting His ways that anyone can commit evil.
5. Moral monstrosities should drive us to pray.
Fewer things are more despicable to our arrogant, insolent world than “thoughts and prayers.” (Evidently it’s much more noble and effective to ‘send good juju.’) Of course, if the living God is Creator of heaven and earth (Nehemiah 9:6), and if he hears us when we make our requests to him through the Son (John 14:13), what could be more effective than to approach the One who is infinite in resources and kindness and generosity?
When professing Christians turn out to be monsters, we should pray, and in four specific ways.
First, we should pray for the return of the Lord Jesus. When Christ is enthroned on earth and all creation is subjected to his Lordship once and for all, ‘all things will be reconciled to Christ’ (Colossians 1:20). This means that everything will be brought into conformity with his righteous character. All sin and rebellion will receive its just punishment, and every injustice will be rectified. Scandals should drive us to pray, “Come, Lord Jesus!” (Revelation 22:20)
Second, we should pray for the person who was hurt. We should pray for their protection and restoration. We should pray that God would bring people into their lives who will love and protect and invest in them for Christ’s sake. We should pray that God would protect their hearts against bitterness and resentment towards him, and that he would bring good into their lives in Christ even out of the unspeakable sins of others against them (Romans 8:28). God is a God who brings death to life and darkness to light.
Third, we should pray for those close to the situation who will no doubt be devastated, including the loved ones and churches connected to the victim and/or the offender. Testimonies will be ruined, and churches will become bywords in the community. The offender might have children or a believing spouse whose lives will be shattered. Unbelievers on the fence will turn away from Christ completely in angry disillusionment. These kinds of sins cause immeasurable destruction in many lives and on many levels, and we should pray for those close to the situation.
Fourth, we should pray that crime is punished and that sin is dealt with. It is a discredit to a people when evil isn’t treated as evil (Isaiah 5:20), and it is destructive for whole societies when crime goes unpunished.
Should we pray for the offender?
Should we pray for the offender in these kinds of situations? If you have the opportunity and are so inclined, pray for genuine repentance and that the Lord may yet forgive. But Scripture does not obligate you to pray for them:
If anyone sees his brother committing a sin not leading to death, he shall ask, and God will give him life—to those who commit sins that do not lead to death. There is sin that leads to death; I do not say that one should pray for that (1 John 5:16; emphasis added).
In this text, John is commanding us to pray for weak and struggling believers. He’s also assuming that the prayers of others on our behalf are one of the privileges of belonging to the household of God. But in the case of professing believers who sin the way that unbelievers sin—willfully, habitually, and without repentance (see 1 John 5:17–18)—they no longer have a right to that privilege. In virtually every situation like the one we’re talking about now, the monster was harboring, hiding, and nurturing some secret sin—and an especially grievous sin at that. All of that comes out when their sin is discovered. In the case of people like that, “I do not say that one should pray for that,” John says. We are not obligated to pray for them.
There are an infinite number of people and things to pray for, and we all have limited time. This is why the Lord teaches us to employ a kind of prayer triage when we enter our closet, and why John says the kinds of things he says in 1 John 5:16. Scripture gives us several priorities that should occupy our prayer energies in circumstances like these, and the offender is not one of them.
This may sound harsh—it’s not intended to—but I believe it’s biblical. In situations like these, the return of Christ, the preservation of the victim, the souls of those involved, and real criminal justice are all higher than the offender on God’s list of priorities. They should be on ours as well.
Come Then, Lord Jesus…
In 1845, a hymn entitled “Come Then, Lord Jesus” was written by Scottish pastor and author Horatius Bonar. It expresses the believer’s longing for the return of Christ in the face of all the evils in the world—the same kinds of evils that we’re talking about in this article. It’s a song worth meditating on at times like these. The lyrics are included below, and you can hear a 2007 version of it by Indelible Grace here.
The Church has waited long Her absent Lord to see
And still in loneliness She waits, a friendless stranger She
Age after age has gone, sun after sun has set
And still, in weeds of widowhood, She weeps a mourner yet
The serpent’s brood increase, the powers of hell grow bold
The conflicts thickens, faith is low, and love is waxing cold
How long, O Lord our God, holy, true and good?
Wilt thou not judge Thy suffering Church—Her sighs and tears and blood?
We long to hear thy voice, to see Thee face to face
To share Thy crown and glory then, as now we share thy grace
Should not the loving bride the absent Bridegroom mourn?
Should she not wear the weeds of grief until her Lord return?
The whole creation groans, and waits to hear that voice
That shall restore her comeliness and make her wastes rejoice
Come, Lord, and wipe away the curse, the sin, the stain
And make this blighted world of ours Thine own fair world again
[CHORUS]
Come then, Lord Jesus, come
Come then, Lord Jesus
Come then, Lord Jesus, come, come, come
- See Deepak Reju, On Guard: Preventing and Responding to Child Abuse at Church (Greensboro, NC: New Growth Press, 2014), 64.[↩ Back to text]
- In 1 Timothy 3:3, Paul says that an elder must be “sober-minded” (ESV). The Greek word is nephálios, which literally means “sober” as in “not drunk,” but figuratively means “clear-minded” or “circumspect.” According to the BDAG, an authoritative Greek lexicon, the verb form of this word (nepho) means “free from every form of mental and spiritual ‘drunkenness’ … [including] rashness, confusion, etc.” Drunk people are senseless and irrational. God requires leaders to be the opposite of that.[↩ Back to text]
- “There is indeed one universal church of the faithful, outside of which nobody at all is saved” (Fourth Lateran Council, 1. Confession of Faith). “Now, therefore, we declare, say, determine and pronounce that for every human creature it is necessary for salvation to be subject to the authority of the Roman pontiff” (Unum Sanctum, Pope Boniface VIII’s 1302 statement of papal supremacy). “[A]ll salvation comes from Christ, the Head, through the Church which is his body. Hence they cannot be saved who, knowing the Church as founded by Christ and necessary for salvation, would refuse to enter her or remain in her” (The Compendium of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, question 171).[↩ Back to text]
- See, for instance, the Shakeshaft and John Jay reports. An interesting article by Jesse Signal is critical of the “100 times more likely” line that’s occasionally thrown around, but he nevertheless demonstrates the fact of higher abuse in public schools than in Catholic churches.[↩ Back to text]

