Why Woodland Park Bible Church is Not a Charismatic Church
Woodland Park Bible Church in San Marcos, CA is not a charismatic church. In this article, we explain what we mean by that and why.

Tony has served as the Pastor-Teacher of Woodland Park Bible Church since January 2025 and is currently earning an MDiv at The Master’s Seminary. He and his wife Beki have been married since 2007 and have four children.
At Woodland Park Bible Church, we are not a charismatic church.
Already some clarifications are needed.
First, when we speak of “charismatics,” we are speaking of those who believe that the miraculous sign gifts seen in the New Testament continue to be in operation today. For this reason, the terms “charismatic” and “continuationist” are used interchangeably in this article—although most people typically do see an important distinction between the two. While “charismatic” generally refers to everything within the first- to third-wave charismatic movements (from Charles Parham, to C. Peter Wagner, to Benny Hinn), “continuationist” typically refers to good men whom we would hold in high regard—such as Wayne Grudem and John Piper—who believe that the miraculous sign gifts continue through today.
Second, when we say that we are not charismatic, we do not mean that God is not able to do miracles, or that God is not able to heal, or that God doesn’t heal people any longer. We also do not mean that we do not believe in the ministry of the Holy Spirit. Unfortunately, many people say that we do mean those things, but that is an irresponsible caricature of what we actually believe.
When we say that we are not charismatics, what we mean specifically is that we are cessationists—that is, we believe that the miraculous sign gifts which we see in the New Testament have ceased and are no longer operating in the church today. We are persuaded that God stopped giving the gifts of tongues, healing, and miracles1 to the church at the end of the time of the apostles. Those gifts were operative in the ministries of Jesus and the apostles, and they have not been operative in the church since. That is what we mean.
There are many reasons why we would be critical of the modern charismatic movement—such as its questionable beginnings,2 or its undermining of the sufficiency of Scripture,3 or the troubling inconsistency between the miraculous gifts as we see them in the New Testament versus how charismatics view and practice them today.4
However, our focus in this article will not be to critique that movement or even to address the gifts themselves (for that we would refer the reader to the sources we’ve cited in this article). What we will try to do is make a simple case for why we are not a charismatic church.
What did the miraculous gifts do?
The message of the Gospel that was first announced by the Lord Jesus and then picked up by his apostles was new revelation from God, and the first after a very, very long silence. By the time John the Baptist appeared on the scene as Jesus’ forerunner, God had said nothing since the prophet Malachi four centuries earlier. Those two facts alone would have made the first hearers of this new message skeptical, but what complicated matters further was that neither Jesus nor his Good News were what anyone was expecting. For good reason, the Jewish people had been anticipating a royal Son of David to rise up in power (2 Samuel 7.12–13), conquer the entire non-Jewish world (Psalm 2, 110), and establish the Kingdom to which all nations would constantly flow to bring tribute to the King in Jerusalem forever (Jeremiah 3.15–18).
But what they got instead was the lowly son of a manual laborer from Galilee, a heavily-Gentile area, and otherwise dubious origins (Mark 6.3). And when he finally went public, so far from conquering the Romans, he was a homeless sage who threatened God’s chosen people with hell if they didn’t repent and place their faith in him (Matthew 4.19, 8.20, John 8.24).
What was demonstrably needed was some kind of authentication that both the Messenger and the message were from God. This, according the New Testament, is precisely the purpose that the miraculous signs and gifts served.
Consider, for instance, Jesus’ words in John 5.36: “the works that the Father has given me to accomplish, the very works that I am doing, bear witness about me that the Father has sent me.” Or 2 Corinthians 12.11–12, where Paul defends his apostleship: “For I was not at all inferior to these super-apostles, even though I am nothing. The signs of a true apostle were performed among you … with signs and wonders and mighty works” (emphasis added). Or, consider the words of the writer of Hebrews, who states that the message of salvation “was declared at first by the Lord, and it was attested to us by those who heard, while God also bore witness by signs and wonders and various miracles and by gifts of the Holy Spirit” (Hebrews 2.3–4, emphasis added).
There are many other passages just like these we could cite (like Matthew 11.2–5; Mark 16.20; John 3.2, 10.25, 10.38, 14.11, 20.30–31; Acts 2.1–16, 2.22, 14.3; or Romans 15.18–19; to name a few), but suffice it to say that the entire function of miracles and signs in the ministries of Jesus and the apostles was to confirm the authenticity of both the messengers and the message—that Jesus, his disciples, and their message of salvation through faith alone in Christ alone were indeed from God. As the foundation of church was laid through the ministry of the New Testament apostles and prophets (Ephesians 2.20)—and as the Word of God was brought to completion with the writings of the apostles providing final, sufficient, inspired, authoritative revelation concerning the Gospel—there was no more need for miraculous authentication of the message.5 It had already been sufficiently authenticated, and the entire record of it was now infallibly recorded by the apostles and in the hands of the Lord’s people.
“Miraculous sign gifts have ceased.” –Church history
Church history confirms not only the authenticating purpose of the sign gifts, but their cessation as well. Up until the 20th century, there is simply no mention in church history of the presence of miraculous sign gifts.6 In fact, we find just the opposite—the mention of the absence of miraculous sign gifts. For example, John Chrysostom, the great fourth-century expositor from Antioch, in his opening sermon on the spiritual gifts section of 1 Corinthians (chapters 12–14), makes precisely that observation. In a long but telling quote, Chrysostom says:
This whole [portion of Scripture] is very obscure: but the obscurity is produced by our ignorance of the facts referred to and by their cessation, being such as then used to occur but now no longer take place.… why did they then happen, and now do so no more? Well: what did happen then? Whoever was baptized he straightway spoke with tongues and not with tongues only, but many also prophesied, and some also performed many other wonderful works. For since on their coming over from idols … they at once on their baptism received the Spirit, yet the Spirit they saw not, for [He] is invisible; therefore God’s grace bestowed some sensible proof of that energy. And one straightway spoke in the Persian, another in the Roman, another in the Indian, another in some other such tongue: and this made manifest to them that were [unbelievers] that it is the Spirit in the very person speaking (emphasis added).7
Three things are worth pointing out from Chrysostom’s quote.
First, he clearly states that the miraculous sign gifts were no longer active in his day, and that they had ceased with the apostolic age 300 years earlier.
Second, he understood the sign gifts as serving to authenticate the work of the Spirit and the message of Gospel.
Third—and not really our point in this article, but still important—Chrysostom did not believe tongues to be unintelligible, ecstatic speech as typically represented among charismatics today, but as actual known human languages that were unknown to those speaking them.8
Chrysostom is not alone; there are many voices from the past we could quote—from Augustine, to Calvin, to Jonathan Edwards, and more.9 The point, however, is clear enough: The Scriptural data indicates the passing away of the miraculous signs and gifts after the time of the apostles, and the record and the testimony of church history confirm that indication.
“The Scriptural data indicates the passing away of the miraculous signs and gifts after the time of the apostles, and the record and the testimony of church history confirm that indication.”
The sufficiency of Scripture or the satisfaction of experience?
Admittedly, there is no ‘silver bullet’ Bible verse that says the sign gifts will cease or have ceased according to a cessationist understanding—but that’s OK, because neither does any text say that the gifts will continue.10
Therefore, what becomes obvious is that cessationists and continuationists both must build a case for their position on other grounds—but that is exactly what both sides do. Both sides are weaving a theological fabric comprised of the relevant biblical texts coupled with an argument from history (past or recent) and/or personal experience.11
Concerning personal experience, Wayne Grudem—a thoughtful continuationist and arguably its most articulate defender—writes the following:
In working on this book [on miraculous gifts] over several months, I began to ask myself, “What is the foundational concern of most Christians in this area?…” What is their deepest concern in all of this discussion about the Holy Spirit and his gifts? I think what people really want is to be in the presence of God. They want to have a deeper personal experience of God… (emphasis Grudem’s)12
The appeal to experience—either as evidence or (according to Grudem) as a goal—is common among many who believe that the sign gifts continue. As cessationists, however, we believe such an appeal implicitly denies the sufficiency of the Word of God.
In the Scriptures, God has given us everything we need to make every decision, navigate every issue, explain every experience, and answer every doubt (2 Timothy 3.16–17, 2 Peter 1.3–4). We do not need ‘a word from the Lord’ or to ‘experience the presence of God’ because we have the Word of God and the biblical promise of his presence (Matthew 20.28). We know that God is omnipotent, good, and doing good even when, for instance, he does not heal us. As cessationists, it is the supernatural nature of God and his Word, the edification of the church, and the conversion of sinners—as well as our knowledge of the spiritual realities that lie beyond our senses—that satisfy us.
Speaking personally, in my 20+ years as a follower of the Lord Jesus, I have never had the Lord ‘speak to me,’ have never ‘felt his presence,’ and have never seen or heard of miracles in my own life or in the lives of anyone else I know. But I also have never felt the need for any of those things in order to elevate or vindicate my faith, a faith which—as I have been intensely aware from the moment of my salvation—is inherently, thoroughly, and necessarily supernatural (John 6.44, 1 Corinthians 1.30, 1 Peter 1.1–5, 8).
In other words, I speak for most cessationists when I say that we are satisfied with what God has revealed in the Scriptures, and we take him at his Word. We do not need personal experience, nor do we trust it (Jeremiah 17.9, Romans 8.35–39, 1 Corinthians 4.4, 1 Peter 1.8, 1 John 3.20).
“We are satisfied with what God has revealed in the Scriptures and we take him at his Word. We do not need personal experience, nor do we trust it.”
One of the most precious truths God has given us in his Word is that the Holy Spirit’s primary ministry in the church age is our edification into greater measures of Christ-likeness by means of the truth of God (John 16.13, 1 Corinthians 2.9–10, 12, 2 Corinthians 3.17–18). Rightly understood, this reality drives us away from a misguided preoccupation with ‘experiencing the Holy Spirit’ in some abstract, emotional or psychological sense, and toward a desire to know God’s Word and to experience his power in our lives through our growth in grace and in conformity to the image of the Lord Jesus.
Clearly much more can been said (and in fact much more has been said by many), but this article, at least in short, explains why we believe what we believe at Woodland Park Bible Church.
- We would also include in this list the gifts of prophecy and apostleship.[↩ Back to text]
- For an overview of the roots of the modern charismatic movement, see Nathan Busenitz, course notes for TH786.OL: Charismatic Theology, The Master’s Seminary, Sun Valley, CA (no date), pgs. 28-42, available at https://bit.ly/4cz1JWW.[↩ Back to text]
- See Bruce Compton, “The Continuation of New Testament Prophecy and a Closed Canon: Revisiting Wayne Grudem’s Two Levels of NT Prophecy,” Detroit Baptist Seminary Journal 22 (2017): pgs. 72 and following, available at https://drive.google.com/file/d/1qHkKMNwIjouzUBpaqMgaNG3MojS4pSuL/view.[↩ Back to text]
- See Nathan Busenitz, Are Tongues Real Foreign Languages? (The Master’s Seminary Journal, Fall 2014), pgs. 69 and following, available at https://tms.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/tmsj25ii.pdf#page=67; and Wayne A. Grudem, “Prophecy, Prophets,” in New Dictionary of Biblical Theology, edited by T. Desmond Alexander and Brian S. Rosner (InterVarsity Press, 2000), pgs. 707 and following.[↩ Back to text]
- See Richard L. Mayhue, “Cessationism, ‘the Gifts of Healings,’ and Divine Healing,” The Master’s Seminary Journal 14, no. 2 (Fall 2003): pg. 269, available at https://tms.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/tmsj14j.pdf.[↩ Back to text]
- Many heretics and doctrinally-aberrant groups throughout church history have claimed to prophesy and/or speak in tongues-like languages, but, understandably, we would not include any of those as part of church history. Either they’ve not been in the church at all (heretics), or else they’ve been outliers and anomalies who have been far off the well-beaten path of New Testament Christianity (the doctrinally-aberrant). Again, see Nathan Busenitz, course notes for Charismatic Theology, pgs. 28 and following, available at https://bit.ly/4cz1JWW.[↩ Back to text]
- John Chrysostom, Homily 29 on First Corinthians, in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, vol. 12, edited by Philip Schaff (Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing Co., 1889), available at https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/220129.htm.[↩ Back to text]
- For a detailed discussion on tongues in the New Testament vs. today, see chapter 7 of John MacArthur, Strange Fire: The Danger of Offending the Holy Spirit with Counterfeit Worship (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2013), pgs. 133 and following.[↩ Back to text]
- Again, see MacArthur, Strange Fire, pgs. 251 and following.[↩ Back to text]
- John Piper and Wayne Grudem both find support for continuationism in the fact that the Bible never explicitly says that the sign gifts have ceased. See John Piper, “Are Prophecy and Tongues Alive Today?,” Desiring God, available at https://www.desiringgod.org/articles/are-prophecy-and-tongues-alive-today, and “Prophecy in the Church Today” by The Proclamation Trust, discussion at Evangelical Ministry Assembly 2010, available at https://vimeo.com/37169587.[↩ Back to text]
- See previous footnote.[↩ Back to text]
- Are Miraculous Gifts for Today? Four Views, edited by Wayne Grudem (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1996), pgs. 346-347.[↩ Back to text]

